Customer Loyalty for Home Services: Why It’s Broken (And How to Fix It)

If you’re in the home services game — HVAC, plumbing, electrical, roofing, pest control — you already know this truth:

Customer loyalty is nearly non-existent.

And it’s not because you’re doing bad work.

It’s because most of your customers don’t remember who the hell you are six months later.

Let’s Talk About the Data

Here’s what the numbers say:

• 🔧 Only 25% of customers use the same plumber or HVAC company again
• (ServiceTitan, 2023)
• 🔍 70% of people hire the first provider they contact
• (LSA & BrightLocal)
• 🧠 46% say they still search online or look at reviews — even if they’ve used you before
• (Podium, 2023)

That means the default behavior is not loyalty — it’s reconsideration.

And in a world where Google results change daily and ads follow them around like stray cats, you don’t stand a chance unless you’re being proactive.

Why Customer Loyalty is So Weak in Home Services

There are a few core reasons:

1. It’s Transactional by Nature

Your customer doesn’t want to see you often. If they do, it means something is broken.

You’re solving an urgent problem, not building a lifelong habit like Starbucks or Netflix.

2. You’re Easy to Forget

Unless you’re showing up regularly (via email, ads, or branded reminders), people move on.

They remember the tech, not the company.

3. There’s No Relationship Layer

Homeowners aren’t building a bond with your brand — unless you give them a reason to.

If they needed you once, they’ll likely need you again. But when they do, they start from scratch. Every. Single. Time.

How to Build Real Customer Loyalty in Home Services

Here’s the good news: Loyalty can be engineered.

You just have to stop treating your business like a one-and-done operation.

Here’s what works (and what we help our clients set up all the time at IMA):

✅ 1. Create a Follow-Up System

After the job is done, most companies disappear.

That’s the opportunity.

Set up a post-service sequence that includes:

• A branded thank-you email or postcard
• A reminder for annual maintenance or seasonal service
• A review request with a personal touch
• Optional: fridge magnet or leave-behind with your brand front and center

👉 Automation tools like ServiceTitan or Copper CRM make this easy.

✅ 2. Launch a Home Protection Plan

You want stickiness? Give people a reason to stay.

Offer a membership program that includes:

• Priority scheduling
• Annual tune-ups
• Discounts on future service
• A small monthly fee (recurring revenue alert 🚨)

This shifts your brand from a one-time fix to a trusted resource.

✅ 3. Retarget Like a Pro

Your website visitors and past customers? Don’t let them disappear.

Use:

• Facebook/Instagram retargeting
• Google Display Ads
• Email remarketing campaigns

Even better — feed your CRM lists into your ad platforms so you’re only paying to stay in front of your warmest audience.

✅ 4. Encourage User-Generated Content (UGC)

People trust people. Not logos.

Encourage your team and your customers to share:

• Before/after photos
• Tech selfies with happy clients
• Short videos from the field

Then, have your agency (hey, that’s us 👋) turn that into scroll-stopping ads and social content that actually builds trust.

The Formula for Customer Loyalty in Home Services

If you want to win the second sale (and third, and fourth), here’s the new math:

Trust + Consistent Visibility + Value = Loyalty

You have to re-earn their business every time. But if you systematize it, you win more often — and spend less on cold leads.

Final Word

At IMA, we work with hundreds of home service brands — from family-owned HVAC companies to fast-scaling multi-location franchises.

They all have the same challenge: customer loyalty for home services is not guaranteed.

But we help them fix that. With a re-engagement strategy. With automation. With branding that sticks.

Want to talk about how to make your business unforgettable?

📞 Book a 15-min Call

📚 See Our Client Case Studies

‍